|
|
||
|
TWN
Info Service on WTO and Trade Issues (Nov26/12) WTO:
US challenges China's practices, rejects agriculture in LPF track Geneva, 17 Nov (D. Ravi Kanth) -- The United States apparently said that it remains concerned about what it considers to be an unsustainable bilateral trade relationship with China, echoing Washington's desire to reduce the likely huge trade deficit of USD 1 trillion a year while alleging that Beijing does not play by the rules, during discussions on the World Trade Organization's reform track on "level playing field" (LPF) issues, the SUNS has learnt. The US trade envoy, Ambassador Joseph Barloon, seems to have delivered a lengthy statement suggesting that the asymmetry in the bilateral trade relationship with China had become too great to be addressed under existing WTO rules. Washington also apparently conveyed that the principle of non-discrimination, including most-favoured-nation (MFN) treatment, could not be applied in the face of continuing asymmetries, according to a person who asked not to be quoted. During the marathon meeting on the WTO reform track on LPF issues on 16 November, the US, alongside the farm-defensive G10 countries, led by Norway, Japan and Switzerland, among others, seemingly opposed calls by a majority of developing countries to include agriculture in the LPF discussions. The US apparently insisted that agriculture should be discussed only in the Committee on Agriculture in Special Session (CoA-SS), and not under the LPF track, according to people familiar with the development. However, several countries, particularly Brazil, apparently issued a notice that there would be no WTO reform package for adoption at the WTO's 15th Ministerial Conference (MC15), scheduled to be held in 2028, without agriculture being part of the LPF track. New Zealand, meanwhile, appears to have signaled that it is considering tabling a document on agriculture, according to people familiar with the discussions. Support for China's proposal At the meeting, several countries also seemed to support China's proposals on LPF. Beijing indicated that it was willing to discuss several elements concerning industrial subsidies on the basis of facts rather than labels. China also appeared to oppose labels such as "non-market economies", while expressing its willingness to discuss different measures and the impact of subsidies, which could be updated within the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (ASCM), according to people who asked not to be quoted. China's proposal for multilateral discussions on industrial policy also gained traction at the meeting, with the European Union indicating its approval, according to people familiar with the discussions. While the US and the EU referred to data provided by the Paris-based Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) on subsidies and state-owned enterprises, China apparently stated that it would accept the OECD's work on state intervention and subsidies, according to a person who asked not to be quoted. Brazil also appears to have made it clear that, alongside agriculture, reform of the dispute settlement system must be an integral part of the LPF discussions. This demand was also echoed by the least-developed countries (LDCs) and members of the ACP (African, Caribbean and Pacific) Group, according to people familiar with the discussions. The demands were raised during the WTO reform discussions on 16 November. The US and several other industrialised countries also appeared indifferent to calls by many Members to include the restoration of the two-tier dispute settlement system in the LPF discussions, according to people familiar with the discussions. ACP for balanced coverage Members of the ACP Group called for discussions on distortions and asymmetries in agriculture, fisheries subsidies and industrial subsidies, while opposing punitive measures in the notifications and compliance segment of the discussions on the WTO reform track on LPF issues on 16 November. Ahead of the meeting, the outgoing facilitator overseeing the WTO reform discussions on LPF issues, Ambassador Elmer Jose German Gonzalo Schialer Salcedo of Peru, issued a room document on 13 November containing questions for the LDCs, the ACP Group, China and Paraguay. In the restricted room document (RD/GC/REFORM/7), the facilitator posed several questions to the ACP Group, including: 1. "The ACP Group highlighted the need to "address structural and historical asymmetries" including "longstanding distortions in agriculture, fisheries and other sectors". To the extent that some of these issues are the subject of ongoing negotiations in other WTO bodies such as the Committee on Agriculture in Special Session and Negotiating Group on Rules, could the ACP Group clarify if it is proposing that these issues also be taken up in the Level Playing Field track, and if so, how we could avoid the duplication of discussions?" [The US, the EU, and the farm-defensive countries led by Switzerland and Japan have opposed bringing the issue of agricultural subsidies into the LPF orbit.] 2. "The ACP Group has proposed an analytical approach where Members should, among others, identify the measure, the relevant WTO provision, available evidence of cross-border trade effects, and affected Members and sector. Could the ACP Group clarify how such an analysis could be used to advance discussions on level playing field given that different measures would affect Members and sectors differently?" 3. "The ACP Group has proposed an analytical approach in its paper, noting that it "must not modify existing agreements, including where proof of adverse trade effects is not required". Could the ACP Group clarify what this refers to, including through providing illustrative examples?" 4. "What role do you see for existing structures and committees as part of due process on notification compliance?" 5. "We agree on the importance of transparency and due process, including ensuring Members have the opportunity to be heard. How do you think the WTO could strengthen this in practice, and could existing mechanisms have a role to play?" In a sharply delineated response, the ACP Group said that, while differences and disparities in institutional capacity and legislative architecture shape their Members' ability to compete, it pressed for "a balanced coverage of all trade-distorting subsidies and measures across agriculture, fisheries and industry." Lesotho, on behalf of the ACP Group, called for examining longstanding asymmetries in agricultural support, capacity-enhancing fisheries subsidies and barriers to value-added exports in the respective WTO bodies, alongside concerns about industrial support, state-owned enterprises and overcapacity. The ACP Group underscored the need for a common approach to examining individual concerns, suggesting that Members should consider how particular measures had disturbed the playing field for them, according to people familiar with the ACP statement. Moreover, the ACP Group argued that discussions on LPF issues should reflect developing Members' need to industrialise, diversify and add value, as well as the importance of "effective special and differential treatment", because development cuts across all reform tracks. On notifications, where some industrialised countries have proposed punitive measures, the ACP Group appears to have called for simpler and better-coordinated notification formats, usable digital tools, timelines consistent with applicable rules, and predictable technical assistance for developing countries facing capacity constraints. As the largest coalition of developing and least-developed countries at the WTO, the ACP Group apparently reiterated "that Members should not discuss punitive measures but positive incentives to strengthen compliance," a position that runs counter to the demand of one major industrialised country, according to people familiar with the discussions. On the widespread use of unilateral measures, particularly by the US over the past one and a half years, the ACP Group said that such measures must be preceded by timely information about their likely impact on developing countries, according to people familiar with the discussions. Significantly, the ACP Group called for "a Member-driven mapping of concrete concerns, the relevant WTO provision, available evidence, development effects and the competent body to follow up." It suggested that Members should agree on the scope and sequence of this work while advancing outstanding mandates in the relevant WTO bodies, Lesotho said on behalf of the ACP Group at the meeting. In short, the ACP Group's position on LPF issues was "practical approaches, that levelling the playing field should cover gaps in addressing all sectors of distortive subsidies, not narrow to industrial subsidies, while at the same time respecting work underway in other relevant bodies." To reinforce its proposed approach, the ACP Group appears to have called for the "use of simpler notification formats and mapping of measures of concern, relevant WTO provision, implication on development policy space and the appropriate WTO body." Response to facilitator's questions Responding to the facilitator's question - "should the LPF track examine distortions in agriculture and fisheries? How would it avoid duplicating ongoing negotiations?" - the ACP Group appears to have stated categorically that "there should be balanced consideration of gaps in addressing agricultural, fisheries and industrial subsidies, barriers affecting developing-country exports, and the historical asymmetry between support available to developed economies and policy tools available to developing Members." It suggested that discussions on LPF issues "can identify specific gaps, examine the evidence and development implications, and identify the competent body for follow-up." Moreover, the ACP Group argued that the LPF "track's findings could inform work in those bodies," while suggesting that "negotiations under existing mandates should continue in the Committee on Agriculture in Special Session and the Negotiating Group on Rules." Responding to another question from the facilitator - "how would the proposed analysis advance the discussion when measures affect Members and sectors differently?" - the ACP Group said that "members could begin with a focused, Member-driven mapping" by identifying "the measure, the relevant WTO provision, the available evidence, sectors affected and the implications for development policy space, which is crosscutting." On the facilitator's question about "what does the ACP mean by preserving existing legal tests, including where proof of adverse trade effects is unnecessary?", the ACP Group apparently suggested that "members consider the relevant WTO provisions under a mapping exercise." As an example, the ACP Group said that "in the case of a prohibited export subsidy, the Member must show that the measure is a subsidy tied to export performance," without having to prove harm. Similarly, "for an actionable subsidy claim, the Member must show that the subsidy targets certain enterprises or industries and causes harm recognised under WTO rules to the Member's trade interests." Regarding the role of WTO bodies in ensuring due process in notification compliance, the ACP Group said that Members should use the competent WTO bodies to understand notification-related concerns and consider how to address them, according to people familiar with the discussions. According to Lesotho, "the ACP Group has long opposed punitive measures for notification shortcomings" and supported "positive incentives to improve compliance, including predictable technical assistance, capacity- building and practical training tailored to Members' needs." Commenting on China's presentation, the ACP Group said it shares "China's emphasis on examining the design and trade effects of specific subsidy measures, including industrial support and preferential financing and the role that well-designed support can play in industrialisation and structural transformation within the applicable WTO rules." The ACP Group asked China to clarify its proposal for creating a WTO forum for industrial policy dialogue and coordination, particularly what such coordination would involve in practice, according to people familiar with the discussions. On Paraguay's proposal (WT/GC/REFORM/W/23), the ACP Group said that it appreciated "the recognition by Paraguay that the WTO must combat all unfair policies and practices." It said that it agreed with Paraguay's proposal that "agriculture must receive comparable attention in the appropriate WTO body," arguing that "historical differences in scheduled domestic support entitlements, market access under tariff rate quotas and recourse to the existing special safeguard are directly relevant imbalances in the playing field." On transparency, notifications and compliance, the ACP Group asked the WTO Secretariat to "explain how it distinguishes missing, late and incomplete notifications? Under GATS Article III:3, Members must promptly and at least annually inform the Council for Trade in Services of new or changed laws, regulations or administrative guidelines that significantly affect trade in services covered by their specific commitments. What has been the track record of notifications submitted under this provision, and how has "promptly" been interpreted?" +
|
||