BACK TO MAIN  |  ONLINE BOOKSTORE  |  HOW TO ORDER

TWN Info Service on Biodiversity and Traditional Knowledge (Nov26/03)
16 November 2026
Third World Network

Risk assessment guidance for living modified fish to be developed, long after first mooted

London, 13 Nov (Eva Sirinathsinghji*) – Parties to the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety have decided to develop an additional voluntary guidance material for assessing the risks of living modified (LM) fish.

The L.11 document containing the decision was adopted at the Cartagena Protocol’s twelfth meeting of the Conference of the Parties serving as the Meeting of the Parties (COP-MOP12), as part of the UN Biodiversity Conference held in Yerevan, Armenia from 19 to 30 October 2026.

Numerous attempts have been made to forward work on such guidance for LM fish, since at least 2018. Decision CP-9/13 had asked COP-MOP10 to consider whether additional guidance materials were needed for LM fish. A study was commissioned and the issue discussed by an Ad Hoc Technical Expert Group (AHTEG) on Risk Assessment.

However, there were diverging views within the AHTEG as to the necessity of guidance materials for LM fish, and COP-MOP10 decided not to proceed, at that stage, with such guidance. Decision CP-10/10 did however ask that Parties consider further guidance for risk assessment of LM fish at COP-MOP11, but this was not done.

Therefore, the issue has finally come to fruition, but the terms may have regrettably changed. The underlying methodological approach to be contained within such future materials – a major point of contention – remains to be determined.

Biotech-friendly countries largely failed in their push for the guidance materials on risk assessment of living modified organisms (LMOs) containing engineered gene drives to be the sole basis for all future guidance materials.

[Concerns have been raised by observers regarding the guidance materials on risk assessment of LMOs containing engineered gene drives, published as Biosafety Technical Series 7.

These include the potential lack of alignment with the precautionary approach and Annex III of the Protocol on risk assessment, as well as questions regarding potential conflicts of interest during its drafting.  Moreover, the approach contained within is an industry-derived method that narrows the scope and framing of risk assessment, reverses the burden of proof and minimises uncertainties.]

The decision instead calls for the development of the guidance material in accordance with Annex III to the Cartagena Protocol, the methodology set out in Biosafety Technical

Series 7 and other methodologies.

Further, it was decided that future capacity building activities on risk assessment would use existing information, guidance materials and approaches to risk assessment of LMOs, in particular those described in Biosafety Technical Series 7.

Contentious issues before COP-MOP12

Requests by Parties for additional risk assessment guidance materials have been made over numerous years. In decision CP-9/13 of 2018, the COP-MOP established a process for the identification and prioritisation of specific issues regarding risk assessment of LMOs, with a view to developing further guidance, in accordance with criteria set out in Annex I of that decision.

The AHTEG in 2025 concluded that seven of thirteen topics submitted by Parties in response to decision CP-11/7 met the criteria for additional voluntary guidance materials.

These topics span novel species applications (LM microorganisms, LM algae, and LM fish), new techniques (LMOs expressing genome editing machinery for pest or pathogen control), as well as covering potential gaps in risk assessment relevant to currently cultivated LM crops (LMOs in centres of origin and traditional agricultural systems, long-term and cumulative impacts of genetic constructs and LMOs, and operationalising protection goals).

Discussions, on the basis of the AHTEG’s outcomes, had already been contentious at the twenty-seventh meeting of the CBD’s Subsidiary Body on Scientific, Technical and Technological Advice (SBSTTA-27), held in November 2025. The SBSTTA-27 recommendation thus contained many brackets, indicating areas of disagreement. (See Discussions on risk assessment of living modified organisms stuck in a loop, 21 November 2025.)

These included three main elements for decision at COP-MOP12: (i) whether or not to develop further voluntary risk assessment guidance materials on one or more of the seven topics; (ii) whether or not to establish an AHTEG to continue such work; and (iii) what existing guidance materials would serve as the basis for future guidance materials as well as for capacity-building activities.

COP-MOP12 also had to determine whether or not to request information on the use of data transportability, the simplified procedure provided in Article 13 of the Protocol, and the bilateral, regional and multilateral agreements and arrangements provided in Article 14 of the Protocol.

This is despite the AHTEG concluding that those topics do not meet the criteria for further guidance materials.

[The concept of data transportability may undermine risk assessment under the Cartagena Protocol, whereby the potential adverse effects of LMOs should be assessed in the likely potential receiving environment. Such a concept has long been promoted by the biotechnology industry as a means to rely on data from other jurisdictions.

The simplified procedure, and bilateral, regional and multilateral agreements and arrangements relate to procedural matters and should not be conflated with simplifying or reducing risk assessment obligations under the Protocol.]

Contact Group discussions yield compromise

Discussions at COPMOP12 went straight to a Contact Group with the bracketed text of the SBSTTA-27 recommendation, in a non-paper, being the basis of negotiations.

While there was broad agreement on the need for developing further guidance materials for new topics, tense discussions arose regarding the nature of future work and the underlying methodology of new guidance materials to be developed.

A few biotech-friendly Parties, one in particular, were initially insistent that no future guidance materials were necessary. They attempted, but ultimately failed, to end the process, including any establishment of a new AHTEG to conduct future work.

From the outset, the biotech-friendly Parties also asserted that the recently developed voluntary guidance materials for LMOs containing engineered gene drives (Biosafety Technical Series 7), could be used for all new topics.

As such, it was suggested that new full guidance materials are no longer necessary. Instead, artificial intelligence (AI) could be used to gather the ‘relevant information’ on all topics, to be curated by a consultant for the development of ‘concise’, ‘focussed’, ‘non-duplicative’ or ‘supplementary’ materials, which could then be peer-reviewed and sent straight to SBSTTA.

In contrast to the historical, consistent opposition by biotech-friendly Parties to the establishment of further AHTEGs and the development of new guidance materials, the proposal was now to increase ‘efficiency’ in addressing Party needs for additional guidance materials – by adopting the methods used in Biosafety Technical Series 7 for all future topics, paired with a streamlined AI process for gathering information on new topics.

Several Parties however raised concerns with regard to the singular focus on using Biosafety Technical Series 7, highlighting the need to include the use of other methodologies. They also wanted to ensure that any materials developed are rooted firmly in Annex III and the provisions of the Cartagena Protocol.

Concerns were also raised with regard to the need to respect the current process of prioritising new topics, and the need to maintain the inclusion of indigenous peoples and local communities, women and youth, in any future process.

Discussions on whether further guidance should be developed were less contentious, though there was a divergence of views regarding which topic(s) should be chosen. There was however broad agreement that new guidance should be limited to one or two topics at the most.

Several Parties expressed interest in the topics of LM microorganisms, LM fish, LM algae as well as LMOs in centres of origin and traditional agricultural systems.

The topic of LM microorganisms is timely, reflecting a surge in interest in contained- and open-release applications. However, a minority of vocal parties opposed this, claiming the topic was too broad.

[It is worth noting that regional and national legislation is currently evolving regarding LM microorganisms, in light of new interests in applications such as biofertilizers, biomining, bioremediation and biopesticides.]

LM fish, instead, proved a less controversial topic for the development of guidance materials, and was finally agreed upon. It is also a topic for which additional guidance materials have been requested several times by Parties.

Proposals to introduce the concept of data transportability, via a paragraph inviting Parties to submit information on their experiences in this regard, were rejected.

However, Parties agreed to invite submissions of information on experiences implementing Articles 13 and 14 in relation to risk assessment. Such information is arguably already required to be submitted to the Biosafety Clearing-House.

Agreement, but more scrutiny needed

After three Contact Croup sessions, Parties agreed that any new guidance materials developed would use all previous guidance materials as the basis. The final decision is “to develop one additional voluntary guidance material in accordance with Annex III to the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, the methodology set out in Biosafety Technical Series 07, which it had welcomed in its decision CP-11/7, and other methodologies”.

This means that Annex III, which is foundational to risk assessment under the Protocol, and the earlier Guidance on Risk Assessment of Living Modified Organisms and Monitoring in the Context of Risk Assessment (published as Biosafety Technical Series 4) are still the basis of risk assessment.

The methodology set out in Biosafety Technical Series 7 is therefore just one of the applicable approaches, but should be carefully evaluated for its appropriateness.

Nonetheless, capacity building activities under the CBD already appear to be using Biosafety Technical Series 7 as the methodological basis. This was the case at the Biosafety Clearing-House and Risk Assessment Training Workshop held in Yerevan on 17 to18 October.

The final main issue of contention was in regard to whether or not an AHTEG would be established to develop the new guidance materials. This was not agreed upon in the Contact Group, and was thus brought to Working Group 2. 

At those discussions, New Zealand and Panama strongly opposed the establishment of an AHTEG. Additional opposition was also raised to the inclusion of observer groups in the AHTEG, as well as to the inclusion of standard text subjecting AHTEG members to the CBD’s procedure for avoiding or managing conflicts of interest in expert groups. These oppositions were ultimately overcome.

Careful reflection is however needed on the invitation to submit information to improve the efficiency of the process of prioritisation of topics for future guidance materials, including through the use of “innovative tools such as artificial intelligence”.

[The use of AI potentially opens the door to its use beyond information gathering. For example, it could be used to determine the relevance of information or to make value judgements on such information.]

Ultimately, attempted manoeuvres at COP-MOP12 to weaken risk assessment methods developed and implemented under the Cartagena Protocol were not entirely successful. However, open and frank discussion on this is now sorely overdue, along with scrutiny over industry interests in the risk assessment process.

Such discussions are now an urgent priority going forward. This is especially needed as the new guidance material on LM fish is developed and as capacity building efforts are carried out.+

(* With inputs from Lim Li Ching)

 


BACK TO MAIN  |  ONLINE BOOKSTORE  |  HOW TO ORDER