TWN Info Service on UN Sustainable Development (Jun18/12)
19 June 2018
Third World Network

Rights : Attack on multilateralism risks mischief on grander scale
Published in SUNS #8703 dated 19 June 2018

Geneva, 18 Jun (Kanaga Raja) - As the attack on the multilateral system and its rules, including most especially international human rights law, intensifies, so too will the risk increase of further mischief on a grander scale, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Mr Zeid Ra'ad Al Hussein, warned on Monday.

Zeid, who late last year announced his decision not to seek a second four-year term, in his last update to the UN Human Rights Council in a regular session, said that "the UN's collective voice must therefore be principled and strong; not weak and whining, obsessed with endless wrangling over process, the small things, as it is the case today."

Zeid also pointed out that historically, the most destructive force to imperil the world has been chauvinistic nationalism - when raised to feral extremes by self-serving, callous leaders, and amplified by mass ideologies which themselves repress freedom.

"The UN was conceived in order to prevent its rebirth. Chauvinistic nationalism is the polar opposite of the UN, its very antonym and enemy," he said.

The Human Rights Council began its thirty-eighth regular session here on Monday (18 June to 6 July 2018).

In his opening statement on Monday morning, Zeid said he heard recently a UN official telling others there is really no such thing as universal human rights, musing that they were picked from a Western imagination.

"I remember thinking to myself that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights - the most translated document in the world - was negotiated by the same political leaders who poured universal values into the Charter, creating the United Nations. Is the UN also then somehow not universal? Were its values sourced only from a Western tradition - unrepresentative of the rest of the world?"

"No," said the High Commissioner, adding that a clear rejection of this comes from a look at the negotiating record itself.

The San Francisco Conference, which established the UN, was a circus of sound shaped from many tongues; its result was not a solo tune from a Western instrument.

Had that been the case - had the countries that joined the organization believed they were being pinned to alien, Western values - why then did they not stream toward the exits? Why did they not withdraw from the UN?

But then why is the Universal Declaration, and the whole body of human rights law that followed it, the object of so much attack now - not only from the violent extremists, like the Takfiris, but also from authoritarian leaders, populists, demagogues, cultural relativists, some Western academics, and even some UN officials, Zeid asked.

"I have spent most of my career at, and in, the UN. What I have learned is this: the UN is symptomatic of the wider global picture. It is only as great or as pathetic as the prevailing state of the international scene at the time.

"I also have come to understand how weak human memory is. That to many people history matters only in so far as it can be unsheathed and flung into political battle: they do not view it as a service to deeper human understanding."

There is a dangerous remove and superficiality to so many of our discussions, so much so that the deepest, core issue seems to have been lost on many, Zeid underlined.

He said is it not the case, for example, that historically, the most destructive force to imperil the world has been chauvinistic nationalism - when raised to feral extremes by self-serving, callous leaders, and amplified by mass ideologies which themselves repress freedom.

The UN was conceived in order to prevent its rebirth. Chauvinistic nationalism is the polar opposite of the UN, its very antonym and enemy.

"So why are we so submissive to its return? Why are we in the UN so silent? "

According to Zeid, the UN's raison d'etre is the protection of peace, rights, justice and social progress. Its operating principle is therefore equally clear: only by pursuing the opposite to nationalism - only when States all work for each other, for everyone, for all people, for the human rights of all people - can peace be attainable.

"Why are we not doing this? Those of us in the UN Secretariat, originating from all the 193 Member States, work collaboratively and we do not answer to any State."

In contrast, said the High Commissioner, too many governments represented at the UN will often pull in the opposing direction: feigning a commitment to the common effort, yet fighting for nothing more than their thinly-thought interests, taking out as much as they can from the UN, politically, while not investing in making it a true success.

The more pronounced their sense of self-importance - the more they glory in nationalism - the more unvarnished is the assault by these governments on the overall common good: on universal rights, on universal law and universal institutions, such as this one.

"And as the attack on the multilateral system and its rules, including most especially international human rights law, intensifies, so too will the risk increase of further mischief on a grander scale. The UN's collective voice must therefore be principled and strong; not weak and whining, obsessed with endless wrangling over process, the small things, as it is the case today."

"If my Office, of which I am very proud, and I, have gotten one thing right over the last few years, it is our understanding that only fearlessness is adequate to our task at this point in time. Not ducking for cover, or using excuses or resorting to euphemisms, but a fearlessness approaching that shown by human rights defenders around the world - for only by speaking out can we begin to combat the growing menace of chauvinistic nationalism that stalks our future," said Zeid.

"I appeal to you to do more, to speak louder and work harder for the common purpose and for universal human rights law, to better our chances for a global peace," Zeid told the audience at the opening session.


The High Commissioner also provided a global update on a number of human rights concerns.

He pointed out that twice in the course of his mandate, he had reported on the troubling failure by a number of countries to grant access, and that he will do so again today.

"These refusals of access constitute a serious affront to our work, and where there is sustained denial of access, and serious reasons to believe violations are occurring, we will consider the option of remote monitoring," he said.

"The Office's mandate to conduct such monitoring is unassailable, and if the Government concerned fears there may be inaccuracies it should permit us in to see the situation on the ground."

In Syria, said Zeid, the leadership's contempt and disregard for human rights was what laid the ground for this conflict, and fuelled it for the first year at least.

The horrific violations and abuses committed since then - principally by the government and its allies, but including also the violent extremists and their supporters - have destroyed much of the country along with many of its people.

Both his Office and the Council's Commission of Inquiry have been refused access to all regions.

The Government's recent, selective acceptance of one Rapporteur's visit, when so many other requests have been outstanding for an extended period, is in no way an adequate stand-in for compliance with this Council's resolutions S18-1 and 19/22, which call for full cooperation with his Office and the establishment of a field presence.

"Our extensive remote monitoring of human rights violations in Syria will continue," Zeid said.

In Myanmar, Zeid said that there are clear indications of well-organised, widespread and systematic attacks continuing to target the Rohingyas in Rakhine State as an ethnic group, amounting possibly to acts of genocide if so established by a court of law.

In Kachin and northern Shan States, conflict has again escalated since October last year, and longstanding and widely reported human rights violations in the country include allegations of extrajudicial killings; enforced disappearances; torture and inhuman treatment; rape and other forms of sexual violence; forced labour; recruitment of children into armed forces; and indiscriminate or disproportionate attacks arising from conflicts between security forces and armed groups.

Although Myanmar has stated that it will investigate allegations and prosecute alleged perpetrators, its actions to date have not met minimal standards of credibility or impartiality.

Due to continuing refusals to permit access, OHCHR, the country Special Rapporteur and the Fact-Finding Mission have conducted remote monitoring.

"In the context of the MOU that the Government of Myanmar has established with UNDP and UNHCR for the repatriation of Rohingya refugees from Bangladesh, I reiterate that no repatriation should occur in the absence of sustained human rights monitoring on the ground, in the areas concerned," said Zeid.

He also said given the gravity and scope of the human rights violations in Venezuela, and continuing denial of access to the Office, "we will continue remote monitoring and reporting; our second report will be published in the coming days - and we firmly believe the Council needs to establish a Commission of Inquiry."

Since last June the Government has issued three invitations to the Special Procedures, the first since 1996.

However, the authorities have ignored a long list of requests by others whose mandates are particularly relevant to the current human rights crisis in the country.

The High Commissioner further reported that despite Burundi's agreement to cooperate with the Team of Experts mandated by the Council last year, the Team was expelled from the country last month and has not been able to return.

Access is also denied to the International Commission of Inquiry set up in 2016, and the authorities have refused to finalize discussions on the renewal of the MOU with his Office.

Meanwhile, the human rights situation continues to deteriorate throughout the country.

The Government's continuing restrictions on civic space, and its decision to revise the Constitution through a referendum last month, have generated a host of human rights concerns - including at least 44 alleged cases of arbitrary arrest and detention - and may further deepen grievances.

Zeid strongly encouraged the Government to re-establish engagement with all international human rights bodies.

In Nicaragua, anti-government protests over the past two months have led to the killing of at least 178 people, almost entirely at the hand of the police forces and by armed pro-government groups, including allegedly the use of snipers, with at least 1,500 wounded. This is in addition to reported abductions and disappearances.

The High Commissioner deplored the violence, including the horrific arson attack two days ago. The gravity of these developments may well merit an international commission of inquiry, he said.

He expects the commitments made at the resumption of the National Dialogue on 15 June to be upheld, including the cessation of all forms of violence and threats thereof, and the commitment to extend an urgent invitation to OHCHR to visit the country, as has repeatedly been requested. This invitation should be sent without delay.

Zeid reported that in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK), remote monitoring by his Office has found little change in the country's longstanding, grave and systematic violations of human rights.

The people of the DPRK risk their lives and their dignity for the exercise of their fundamental human rights, including seeking to leave the country and communicating with individuals abroad.

"While I regret the persistent lack of cooperation with the country mandate-holder, the DPRK's recent engagement with the human rights mechanisms, through one Special Rapporteur visit and treaty body reviews, is encouraging".

Zeid called on the authorities to step up that engagement significantly, an d without selectivity, including cooperation with the country mandate.

"The experience of my Office has repeatedly demonstrated that making human rights part of peace talks contributes to meaningful and sustainable peace in the long-term. Our door remains open for greater engagement and cooperation."

The High Commissioner pointed out that Israel continues to deny access to the Occupied Palestinian Territory by the Special Rapporteur on the Situation of human rights in the Palestinian territory occupied since 1967.

This has been the case for three successive holders of the mandate. Access has also been denied to all of the Council's previous Commissions of Inquiry, including on Gaza in 2014.

"I believe the Council's advocacy of impartial monitoring and expert recommendations is entirely justified by the gravity of the situation, and I urge Israel to provide access to all human rights mechanisms - including the investigative body mandated last month - to enable impartial monitoring and advance accountability and justice."

Regarding the situation in Turkey, an invitation for the High Commissioner to visit Ankara is not a substitute for access for the Office to directly and objectively assess the situation in the South-East, where the authorities have consistently failed to conduct credible criminal investigations into the civilian deaths which occurred during security operations in 2015 and 2016.

In the absence of adequate access, the Office will continue remote monitoring of the situation.

Zeid noted that Turkey received visits relating to torture, freedom of expression and enforced disappearances in 2016, and he encouraged the government to allow further visits in the near future.

Unconditional access to Bahrain continues to be refused to his Office and the Special Procedures, amid continued crackdowns on civil society and additional legislation which further restricts the people's fundamental rights.

"I encourage the Kingdom to reverse these profoundly damaging trends and to facilitate effective engagement with the international human rights mechanisms. My Office stands ready to provide technical and legal expertise."

In South Sudan, Zeid acknowledged and welcomed the Government's cooperation with the Council's Commission on Human Rights in South Sudan.

However, in violation of the Status of Forces Agreement, human rights officers working with UNMISS have been regularly denied access to locations where serious human rights violations and abuses are allegedly committed, impeding UNMISS's mandated task of monitoring the human rights situation.

These include facilities run by the National Security Service, where hundreds of people are believed to be arbitrarily detained in conditions that could amount to torture.

"I am deeply concerned about the intensification of indiscriminate attacks against civilians, particularly a pattern of rapes and killings perpetrated by Government forces and their proxies in Unity State since April 2018," said Zeid.

Human rights officers have documented the rape of children as young as four years old, and numerous cases of women, elderly people and others being hanged or burned alive in what appears to be a deliberate scorched-earth policy.

Zeid also welcomed Security Council resolution 2414 (2018) on Western Sahara, which strongly encourages enhancing cooperation with OHCHR.

"I reiterate the readiness of my Office to undertake as soon as possible a follow-up technical mission to Western Sahara."

The High Commissioner also pointed out that almost 40 States have received no visit by a Special Rapporteur over the past five years, despite requests.

Among them, 15 States have more than five pending visits: Bahrain, Belarus, Bolivia, Colombia, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Jamaica, Nicaragua, Pakistan, Turkmenistan, Uganda, Yemen and Zimbabwe.

"I take this opportunity to emphasise that attempts by Governments to selectively cherry-pick which mandates they will invite to their country undermine the integrity of the entire international human rights architecture, their own commitments to the equality and dignity of all their people, and the authority of this Council," said the High Commissioner.

There is also no exception to the requirement of cooperation for States in disagreement with the majority of Council members: indeed such an approach would eviscerate the meaning of the Council's decisions.

"I deplore the openly voiced refusal of a number of States to cooperate with this Council's Independent Expert on sexual orientation and gender identity."

Notably, said Zeid, the Russian Federation has formally refused to respond to any communications from the mandate-holder, including joint submissions without her experts mandated by the Council, despite serious allegations of violence, discrimination and exclusion of members of the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community, especially in Chechnya.

In many States, LGBTI people face severe and often official discrimination; and almost everywhere, they are inadequately protected from violence and bigotry.

"Protecting all human beings, including the LGBTI community, is not "outside" the international legal framework; ending discrimination and violence for everyone, everywhere, is absolutely central to our principles and work," said Zeid.


At the same time, the High Commissioner said that he is pleased to note a number of positive developments with respect to access for the Special Procedures.

These include an increased response rate to communications, now at 68 per cent (an increase of 13 per cent over 2016); and Afghanistan's issuance of a standing invitation to all mandate-holders, taking the number of States having done so to 118 UN Member States and one non-member Observer State.

He noted and commended the following States which have hosted at least five visits by thematic mandates in the last five years: Argentina, Australia, Azerbaijan, Brazil, Chile, Georgia, Ghana, Greece, Honduras, Italy, Kazakhstan, Mexico, Republic of Korea, Serbia, Sri Lanka, Tunisia, Ukraine, the UK and the US.

Regarding engagement with the Treaty Bodies, Zeid welcomed long-outstanding reports to the Committees by Bangladesh, Cabo Verde, Central African Republic, Guinea, Mali, Mauritania, Niger, Tonga and Zambia.

Zeid further said that people do not lose their human rights by virtue of crossing a border without a visa.

"I deplore the adoption by many countries of policies intended to make themselves as inhospitable as possible by increasing the suffering of many already vulnerable people. In recent weeks, I have become increasingly alarmed by two issues regarding access for civil society organisations to migrants."

In Hungary, Zeid said he is deeply concerned about a bill presented to Parliament last month which, if adopted, would effectively criminalize human rights monitoring at borders and within border zones, as well as criminalizing the provision to migrants of information, legal aid and assistance.

The bill would also eliminate or impede judicial review in many cases. It i s essential that independent monitoring bodies - including not only all international human rights bodies, but also national human rights institutions and civil society - be able to monitor the human rights situation of migrants without fear or obstruction.

These prohibitions, and related measures adopted by the Government of Hungary in recent months, stigmatize and harm migrants in vulnerable situations and those who seek asylum, as well as punishing the admirable work of human rights defenders who seek to help them.

In the United States, Zeid said that he is deeply concerned by recently adopted policies which punish children for their parents' actions. In the past six weeks, nearly two thousand children have been forcibly separated from their parents.

The American Association of Pediatrics has called this cruel practice "government-sanctioned child abuse" which may cause "irreparable harm," with "lifelong consequences".

The thought that any State would seek to deter parents by inflicting such abuse on children is unconscionable, said the High Commissioner.

"I call on the United States to immediately end the practice of forcible separation of these children, and I encourage the Government to at last ratify the Convention on the Rights of the Child, in order to ensure that the fundamental rights of all children, whatever their administrative status, will be at the centre of all domestic laws and policies."

"We request access so we can better work to help bring States' laws and practices in line with the commitments which they themselves have made. Every decision to engage more productively with the human rights system is a decision to create openings towards a more harmonious society - one where there is greater justice, more sustainable peace and better development," said Zeid.

"I am heartened by the new areas where access has been achieved over the past year. It is not easy to highlight conflicts which have been averted, violations which have been warded off, and spiralling violence that has been interrupted and diminished.

"But every step towards greater implementation of the human rights agenda is an act of prevention, which gathers and strengthens the bonds between communities and reinforces inclusive development and peace."

Zeid said he is convinced that the human rights ideal has been the most constructive movement of ideas in our era - and among the most successful.

Over the past 70 years, a sustained peace has been achieved in and between many societies. Conflicts have been resolved, with respect and through law; a vastly increased number of people have been able to meaningfully express their views, and access education, healthcare and opportunities for development, without discrimination.

Some may take these achievements for granted. But they are the enactment of policies - policies and laws that uphold the universal principles of human dignity and equality.

And they are not the norm. Every society's history is bloody with conflict and deprivation: we need only look back a little way to grasp the dangers, which our work averts.

When leaders undermine human rights, and human rights law, this is in no way an act of patriotism. They are eroding the structures which can ensure the safety of their people - pitching their societies backwards into violence, destruction, exploitation and disaster.

They are recreating the rule of brute force and exploitation - within countries and between them. True patriotism consists in viewing every State, and humanity as a whole, as a community of mutual responsibility, with shared needs and goals . True patriotism consists of the work of creating tolerant communities, which can live in peace.

"I depart an Office which is strong, absolutely committed to its gargantuan task, and which, in the face of heavy headwinds, has made progress. These new areas of access are a testament to the credibility of our operations and the justice of our cause," said Zeid.

"I remain convinced that the monitoring and reporting we have achieved; our capacity-building for civil society and States; and our clear, steady and impartial advocacy have been significant contributors to governance that is more inclusive and respectful of the rights of the people; societies which are more peaceful; and development that is broader, deeper and of more benefit to all," he added.