No revolution without feminism: Weaving together Venezuela's feminist movements
Amidst a complex reality, feminist movements in Venezuela look to advance their struggle and build unity.
INTERNATIONAL Working Women's Day, 8 March, landed this year in the midst of a complex scenario in Venezuela, with an ongoing coup attempt and a simmering threat of foreign intervention. Juan Guaido, the latest opposition leader, had sworn himself in as 'interim president' on 23 January, a move that was followed by escalated international aggression against Venezuela.
In this context, the natural tendency is to close ranks and centralise discourse, as much as possible, against the foreign threat. The tension paralysed popular movements to a certain degree, calling on everyone to defend the country. Nevertheless, as 8 March approached, several feminist movements held meetings to discuss the agenda and struggle.1
Feminism in times of coup
Alejandra Laprea, a member of the Feminist Spider Network (La Arana Feminista) and of the Purple Ink collective (Tinta Violeta), told us that despite standing firm against a possible invasion, popular struggles cannot be left 'for later'.
'Capitalism, patriarchy, are like weeds. If they're not pulled out at once, at the root, they reproduce. That is why even in a country under threat and under siege we cannot leave it "for later", because otherwise, regardless of the outcome, the right wing will win.'
However, feminist movements internationally were calling for a strike on 8 March. But, with opposition leader Guaido also talking about a strike, there was a risk that a women's strike in Venezuela would end up boosting the efforts to topple the Bolivarian government. With that in mind, the feminist movements' consensus was to reaffirm their solidarity with feminist struggles worldwide, but without calling their mobilisation a 'strike'. The slogan 'We Strike' ('Nosotras Paramos') seamlessly turned into 'We Fight', or 'We Struggle' ('Nosotras Luchamos').
Laura Franco, spokeswoman from the Lydda Franco Farias Popular Feminism Movement, explained this necessary balance: 'We understand the internationalist dynamic and embrace the struggle of all women who, like us, struggle against all kinds of oppression around the world. But in our national context we decided that "we fight", not as something opposed to the call for a strike but simply adjusting it to our reality. Today Venezuela is facing the most serious threat of a war it has seen in the past 20 years, with an ongoing coup.'
The risk of embarking on a mobilisation that in the current context could have ended up playing into the hands of the coup was a concern, which was spontaneously resolved with an unambiguous slogan: 'No Revolution Without Feminism' ('Sin Feminismo No Hay Revolucion').
The march that was prepared was put in doubt by the possible holding of an 'official' march on 8 March. Were that to be the case, the idea would be for these feminist movements to march as a block, since a separate march did not make sense. They would, however, make small detours from the official route to make specific stops (see below).
In the end, the true obstacle was a power outage that left more than 70% of the country in the dark after an alleged cyberattack against the electricity grid. With no transportation or communications, Caracas and the rest of the country were brought to a standstill. Nevertheless, several women managed to meet and march to Caracas' Plaza Bolivar, with another improvised and appropriate slogan, 'With or without power, we fight.'
Weaving struggles together
There are currently a number of feminist movements in Venezuela. Although many struggles naturally precede Chavez, the feminist movements that debated and prepared ahead of 8 March can be considered part of the Bolivarian camp, with varying levels of closeness and criticism with respect to the state.
To this diversity we must add the 'conflict and cooperation' relation between popular organisations and the state, and the co-optation logic that is always there, regarding both the agenda and bringing people from the popular movement into the state institutions. Once on the inside, the struggle is between the 'normal functioning' of the state and the need to subvert it.
Therefore, the current challenge is to build unity among popular feminist movements. Or, as Alejandra puts it, weave them together ('tejer'). 'For us as a network [the Feminist Spider], it is very important to build links between different organisations so that our banners grow stronger. In that sense "weaving" is a metaphor we have used for many years.'
During several meetings and discussions, feminist companeras from different movements were also literally weaving/knitting, using recycled materials and threads donated in solidarity by the Chilean chapter of the World March of Women. 'Faced with an economic war and blockade, our response is to create, produce and weave solidarity among us,' Alejandra added. The end result was a banner that can be seen in the accompanying photograph.
In this regard, the idea was then to stage a march in Caracas on 8 March with several stops. At each stop a banner would be unfurled, with one or more collectives taking the lead in the action.
One of the struggle fronts that was present belonged to the Tenants' Movement, which is part of the Settlers' Movement, with a particular focus on eviction resistance.
'Patriarchy has as a consequence that most Venezuelan households are headed by women. Therefore, most tenants are women! That is why we are taking part in this feminist platform, to defend housing as a fundamental right,' stressed Maria Fernanda Lopez Leiva, a member of the movement.
Maria Fernanda said that the number of evictions is on the rise, despite the existence of laws protecting tenants. 'It is a contradiction that in a supposedly socialist state a family can be thrown out on the street. At the end of the day the issue is class struggle, because tenants are from the pueblo, they are workers who cannot afford to buy a home,' she explained.
Among the demands or banners, the struggle for sexual and reproductive rights had an important place. Taking advantage of the fact that there is an ongoing constituent process, movements have pressed the National Constituent Assembly to advance their agenda in the new draft constitution on issues such as legalising abortion (which is currently penalised in Venezuela) or same-sex marriage.
There was also an effort to bring campesino (peasant) and indigenous movements on board. The social reproduction that results in the responsibilities of the home falling on the shoulders of women is not exclusive to urban settings. As a consequence, women in the Venezuelan countryside are also affected by violence. One of the planned stops of the march was precisely the Ministry for Agriculture and Land, to demand answers to several unresolved cases of campesino struggles for land.
A common thread to many current feminist battles is the existence of very advanced legislation, such as the law protecting tenants or the land law, which are, however, not enforced. This grants a legal basis to demand action from the state, and at the same time shows that having advanced legislation is not enough to change a macho, patriarchal culture in society and in state institutions themselves.
A very dramatic case was the recent murder of Mayell Hernandez. The young mother and dancer was killed and everything pointed towards her ex-partner, yet it took an intense campaign and mobilisation from feminist movements in order to finally spur the Attorney General's office into action.
The Organic Law on the Right of Women to a Life Free from Violence is another important example of an advanced piece of legislation which is not enforced. Be it because prosecutors classify crimes not as gender violence but as crimes of passion, or because the dominant patriarchal culture leads to 'losses' of evidence, the result is a piece of legislation that does not fulfil its role in stopping violence against women.
'Feminist' Chavez as an ally
'The world has always been machista. That is why I declare myself a feminist. The socialist revolution should be feminist,' Chavez said in a 2011 speech. This is one of the many cases where one of Chavez's main qualities shone, namely his ability to 'talk' directly to popular movements without the intermediation of the state. Though his notion of feminism is not necessarily the one espoused by feminist movements, his position offers an important tactical advantage.
'We claim the feminist Chavez,' Laura explained. 'While for some feminist movements it may seem contradictory that we claim a man, and a military man at that, it is thanks to Hugo Chavez that we could open a dynamic of participation that was denied to us before.'
This dynamic of participation is what has generated this plethora of feminist movements under the umbrella commonly referred to as Chavismo, grouped around different banners of struggle and with different levels of tolerance and cooperation with state institutions. The state will continue to be there, with its generally progressive content and its contradictions, and the challenge is to continue building the revolution.
'We have to find a way, as a people and as a feminist movement, to move forward in the construction of the feminist and socialist revolution, without leaving any banner behind, without thinking that one struggle is more important than any other,' Alejandra summarised.
Amidst a coup and amidst an economic war/crisis; with or without the state; with or without power, feminist movements will continue raising their banners and weaving their unity. The progress, or the mere survival, of the revolution will only be assured by the leading role and the achievements of popular movements. And there is no revolution without feminism.
Ricardo Vaz is a writer and editor with Venezuelanalysis.com, from which this article is reproduced.
The movements that took part in the meetings leading up to 8 March were the following (original names in Spanish): La Quinta Ola, Brigada Feminista Latinoamericana, Tinta Violeta, Movimiento de Feminismo Popular Lydda Franco Farias, La Estafeta, Faldas-R, Frente Cultural de Izquierda, Rebeldia Lesbica, VenezuElla, La Arana Feminista, Universidad Popular de las Comunalidades, Organizacion de mujeres indĄgenas Yukpa Oripanto Oayapo Tuonde, Tetas en Revolucion, Colectivo Cimarr˘n, Genero con Clase, Movimiento de Mujeres Clara Zetkin, Plataforma Golpe de Timon, Movimiento de Inquilinos (Plataforma de Pobladores).
*Third World Resurgence No. 337/338, January/February 2019, pp 54-56